Published studies suggest that about 1 in 10 radiology reports include a recommendation for additional imaging or follow-up, and that 25–35% of recommended additional imaging is never completed. In Inflo Health’s analysis of nine health systems, follow-up closure gaps ranged from 40% to 50%.
To understand why, we held two focus groups this year with 16 imaging leaders from academic medical centers, integrated delivery networks, community health systems, and outpatient imaging networks, and surveyed each participant beforehand. Our new research brief shares what they told us. Here are the headlines.
Most organizations can’t see the gap
Ten of 16 survey respondents said they have no reliable way to measure whether follow-up happens. Only three regularly track and report closure.
When we asked where the follow-up chain breaks, the most common answer wasn’t a clinical step at all. It was “no one tracks whether follow-up occurred.” In total, 13 of 16 leaders pointed to a lack of visibility. The three who didn’t were the same three who measure closure.
One leader summed it up: “No way to measure it. And I just didn’t know where to go.” Others described dashboards they didn’t trust, tracking spreadsheets that never reach the EHR, and no way to confirm follow-up when patients get care somewhere else.
If you can’t see the gap, you can’t close it. You also can’t build the business case to fund closing it.
Breast and lung work. Everything else is on its own.
Fourteen of 16 organizations have a structured follow-up process for lung nodules and for breast findings. Only eight have one for non-lung incidental findings, five for cardiology or AAA, and one for vascular findings.
Breast and lung programs succeed because guidelines, regulation, registries, and dedicated navigators give them structure. Other actionable findings rarely get that support. As one participant described it: “there’s almost next to no follow-up. It’s just, hey, we’ve recognized this is abnormal in the study. Good luck.”
Leaders feel pressure to cover more finding types. But standing up a new program for every condition only adds to the silos they already manage. What’s needed is one approach for all actionable findings.
When everyone owns follow-up, no one does
Seven of 16 respondents said no one clearly owns the follow-up gap. Only three named the same group as both owner and funder, and 11 of 15 called budget and competing priorities their biggest barrier.
“Who owns it, right? We all own it,” one leader said. Responsibility is spread across radiology, ordering providers, quality teams, and patients, which in practice means no one is accountable. Where programs did work, someone had been named: “the decision that radiology was going to own the process from start to finish was a key factor.”
Navigators can’t carry it alone
The most widely shared theme: 10 of 16 participants described programs that depend on navigators who are expensive, hard to hire, and often unavailable. Without them, follow-up becomes what one leader called “almost like a collateral duty.”
Manual review is also slow work with little payoff. One leader described staff checking 50 patients to find two who still needed something scheduled. Add workforce shortages, rising volume, and burnout, and a people-only model can’t keep up.
Patients are reading results first
Under the 21st Century Cures Act, imaging results often reach patient portals right away. Half of survey respondents said patients sometimes read results before their provider calls. Anxious patients then call radiology, where “the only person they can get a hold of is a technologist sitting in a modality that’s not allowed to give them any information.”
Follow-up processes now need to assume the patient may be the first person to read a recommendation, and explain in plain language what it means and what happens next.
Better follow-up starts with better recommendations
Every later step depends on a clear, specific recommendation. Yet of the six organizations we asked, only one checks recommendations against guidelines, and only one flags findings that have no recommendation. Participants also described inconsistent or outdated report templates. Supporting radiologists here, without adding to their workload, is where closing the loop begins.
What this means for imaging leaders
The leaders we spoke with traced follow-up failures to how the process is built, not to individual effort. Follow-up needs infrastructure, not heroics: a consistent way to identify recommendations, track them to completion, and measure results, so people can focus on the cases that need their judgment.
The case for funding it will vary. Academic centers and large networks most often pointed to downstream revenue; community systems more often cited liability, patient experience, and regulatory coverage.
A few questions to bring to your next leadership meeting:
- Can we report our follow-up closure rate today?
- Who owns follow-up from report to completed exam, and who funds it?
- Do incidental findings get the same rigor as lung and breast?
- What happens when a patient reads the recommendation before anyone calls?
Read the full research brief for the complete survey results, all seven focus group themes, and our recommendations. Download the brief →